Make any occasion a celebration

A delight for every guest

From Sara’s Tipsy Pies to the breadth of our other fresh-baked offerings, we’re bursting with ideas for how to make events of any size deliciously memorable. Just share your vision with us and we’ll share a world of possibilities with you.

Let Sara help you plan your event!

Reserve a time to come in for a conversation about your upcoming gathering. Whether large or small, we’ll talk you through all your options for a dazzling dessert spread.

Pies are just the beginning

Sara’s Bake Shop wows with fruit pies and satisfies with savory ones. She also offers cookies, tarts, pie pops, bars, bombs and donuts, along with breads you thought no one but your grandma could bake. And be sure to ask about Sara’s seasonal offerings.

Contact Us

Pies with a Purpose

A portion of every purchase enables Sara’s Bake Shop to make a year-end donation to the Valley Friendship Club Stillwater. We do it in honor of Sara’s daughter, Madi, and every person with Down Syndrome.

Learn More

Celebrations Gallery

Praise from our customers

“Her set up was beautiful and her pie and tarts were absolutely delicious. Sara also made us a cake which was equally as good. Event guests raved about the pie and about how unique it was to serve pie at an event such as ours. I wholeheartedly recommend Sara and her delicious pies to anyone looking to impress guests!”
“You cannot go wrong with Sara’s pies! They’re perfect if you and your guests are pie lovers. Also it’s nice that she’ll deliver and set up the dessert table too, it saves so much time on the day of! Also instead of splitting a mini pie with your groom-to- be, she’ll make you a heart shaped pie of your choice! They’re super cute!”— Amanda P.
“Thank you Sara Higgins-Hayden for helping make my sister’s wedding extra special. Your fresh strawberry pies were amazing and clearly a labor of love. Your attention to detail, including going to over 10 farmers’ markets to find the perfect locally-grown strawberries demonstrates how special and unique you and your budding enterprise are. I heard many guests, including my 3 daughters, comment that they now want pies for their future weddings!”— Renee Thompson Arnold and Maria Arnold at Schultz Lake
“Loved working with Sara! LOVED the pies! Loved that a portion of the proceeds goes to a charitable organization which we already support. All our guests love the pies, cupcakes and cookies! Sara was easy to work with, responsive, on-time and provided delicious treats for our guests.”
“Sara made Irish Apple, French Silk, and Lemon Meringue pies for our wedding in November of 2015. They were the highlight of our wedding! When we met with Sara for our tasting, we mentioned wanting lemon meringue. This wasn’t a pie she typically made BUT Sara went above and beyond to make it for us. Sara delivered the pies and explained to the reception staff exactly how they should be set up. She did a fantastic job! The heart shaped hand pies and pie pals were BEAUTIFUL! If you are looking for something unique and equally delicious to serve at your wedding, look no further. Thank you for making our day so special, Sara!”— Jillian Cole
“Wow! From our first meeting with Sara to taste pie, it was clear how passionate she is about her business and the quality of her product. Our wedding pies were a huge hit with our wedding guests, totally cleaned out (in fact, the only “complaint” I have is that I wish we had ordered more pies!). Sara made us a larger pie to cut, which was gorgeous. And the wooden stands to display our pies were a perfect match to the hand pies. We would recommend her tasty, tipsy pies to anyone looking for a creative take on wedding dessert”— Cassie B.

Subscribe to our newsletter for product specials, company news and exclusive event information!

Email Signup